On 6/15/06, Jonathan Ragan-Kelley < katokop1@gmail.com> wrote:

Why should the user have to explicitly specify a list of contexts in a
separate file -- why couldn't contexts just be inferred from those the
user is already using, like in FMP? They could of course be cached in
a .context_cache file for faster access, but it seems to me that
having an explicit, separate configuration file is entirely
unnecessary.

FMP is pretty much the opposite of the current bundle, more of less. As I understand it, FMP allows a user to add tasks into a single list, which is then used to create separate context based lists. What I am trying to do with the GTD bundle is to enter tasks into project lists (separate files) that can then be used to create context based lists (right now it's a single list view, organized by context).

Having said that, the purpose of the contexts.gtd file is to allow a user to create user-specific contexts, e.g., @MOM'S_HOUSE. There will be a base set of contexts that are already in the bundle (TASK, CALL, EMAIL, etc.). If there is a way to build it into the bundle without a separate file, I'd be glad to use it. The separate file is based on my limited coding skills and knowledge of TextMate.

The other complexity I don't yet fully grok is why there is this
notion of task-type that's orthogonal to both context and project.
>From my own experience, at least, this sort of added layer of
complexity over and above basic GTD (traditionally you just have
@email, @work and @home, not tasks vs. email vs. ? | @home vs. @work
leading to email@home vs. task@work) always winds up getting trimmed
away in the end, and, where the distinction is genuinely useful, it's
usually because you actually have a new context distinction
(@work-email and @home-email), not because these sorts of things need
to be fundamentally orthogonal throughout, complexifying the system
even in cases where the location is irrelevant.

I think this actually meshes with the first part, based on what a user wants. I'm pretty happy with just TASK, EMAIL, CALL, BUY, etc., but a few folks want to be able to create more detailed contexts. I think this method supports both preferences.

Anyway, just my 2c after watching from a distance for a while. I'm
quite interested to see where this goes.