Alain,
I did not have good luck with modifying the plist files for TextMate or TeXShop either. However I installed Ciaran's excellent Quicklook plugin, and modified the plist file for the plugin to include org.tug.tex. Complete instructions are on his blog. http://ciaranwal.sh/
Make sure that you restart Finder, or run qlmanage -r from the command line. I think glmanage is the most reliable way to make sure things work.